Recommend

Wednesday, March 05, 2008

About Banning on Guestbook...

From Teacher: I'm all for it webmaster. But, where do you draw the line. Politics is an interesting subject, unfortunately it deals with many different aspects and opinions. Not that I condone the behavior of some alumni. Some of these people need to get educated on what they fight for. If this is a teaching moment than so be it. A well rounded, moralistic and knowledgeable person, may it be a professional or not must atleast try to appease the situation. Even if we have to conform to their level of perspective.

Dear Teacher: I do admit that we must accept the fact that if a public official is not performing in the interest of the community that it needs to be pointed out. Politicians should know that the public has a right to make their opinions known. A sampling of what we have had to remove; that in most cases few get to see; include an accusation that a certain elected official was stealing money. The official's name was given and no other facts. Another example named a school educator that was having an affair with another named individual. We must also recognized that this started out to be a guestbook and it has ended up being a gossip column. Althought we have created an additional guestbook for those that want to post friendly or personal messages, few use it because it does not have juicy stuff. To answer the question of where do I draw the line, I draw the line when the intent is clearly malicious. I don't know about you but I don't care to know who is having an affair. That is not important to me although it might be important to others. If the morality of educators is important then contact someone who can do something about it. You should also know that anyone who creates a media (guestbook) for others to make comments, shares a legal responsibility or liability because he makes it possible for that person to libel someone else. I have had to answer to attorneys in the past because of someone's belief that their malicious comment was a matter of freedom of speech. Just today I dealt with another problem where I talked with the parents of someone that posted a troubling message. Keep in mind that yesterday we had 5,976 people visit our website and of those I only had one problem. You mentioned that politics deals with many different aspects and opinions. I agree with you 100%. Personally I enjoy politics as much as others like sports. One of my degrees is in Political Science and it has been an interest of mine even when I attended Webster Elementary. Politics should not be taken as serious as it is and comments and opinions should be stated freely without any concern for retribution. After 12 years of having our website online I know that most politicians visit the site daily and they provide me with the information that is sometimes needed. During this last local elections someone was writing that one of the candidates had a long criminal history and nothing else. I didn't think that was fair because the insinuation was damaging and the writer refused to be specific. In conclusion, I don't pretend to think that this site has some noble cause and that it is the pillar of our community. This is just a simple site that anyone can create.